"Killing Me Softly With His Song" - a song about another song

Saturday, 26 July 2025 08:22

From Don McLean to Roberta Flack to the Fugees, the evolution of an iconic song

"Killing Me Softly with His Song." It's a title that evokes deep emotion, instantly bringing to mind the soulful voice of Roberta Flack. This iconic track, a staple on airwaves for decades, tells a tale of vulnerability and the profound impact a piece of music can have on a listener. But the story behind "Killing Me Softly" isn't about a song that's "awful"; it's about a song that was so deeply, powerfully resonant, it felt almost overwhelming.

The genesis of "Killing Me Softly with His Song" lies with a then-young singer-songwriter named Lori Lieberman. In 1971, Lieberman attended a concert by folk singer Don McLean, famous for his epic hit "American Pie." As McLean performed his song "Empty Chairs," something about his delivery and the raw emotion in his lyrics struck Lieberman profoundly. She felt as though McLean was singing directly about her life, exposing her deepest feelings, and articulating unspoken truths she carried within her. It was an experience that left her feeling deeply moved and, paradoxically, a little exposed – as if his song was "killing her softly" with its truth and understanding. It wasn't a negative "awful" feeling, but rather an intense, almost unsettling recognition of her own emotions laid bare by someone else's music.

Inspired by this powerful encounter, Lori Lieberman jotted down her feelings in a poem. She shared this poem with her songwriting partners, Norman Gimbel and Charles Fox. Gimbel, a renowned lyricist, immediately saw the potential in Lieberman's evocative words. He and Fox then collaborated to craft the music and refine the lyrics, turning Lieberman's personal reflection into the song we know today. Lieberman herself released the first version of "Killing Me Softly with His Song" in 1972.

However, it was Roberta Flack's interpretation that catapulted the song to global superstardom. The story goes that Flack heard Lieberman's version on an in-flight radio while flying back from Los Angeles. Deeply captivated by the lyrics and melody, she reportedly called her producer, Quincy Jones, from the plane to tell him she had found "the song." Flack poured her signature soulful delivery and meticulous phrasing into the track, lending it an unparalleled emotional depth. Her rendition, released in 1973, became an instant classic, topping charts worldwide and earning her a Grammy Award for Record of the Year and Best Pop Vocal Performance, Female. It resonated with millions who understood that feeling of music speaking directly to their soul.

Decades later, "Killing Me Softly" found new life when the hip-hop trio The Fugees released their cover in 1996. Featuring Lauryn Hill's distinctive vocals, their version introduced the song to a new generation, blending its timeless melody with a fresh, contemporary sound. It too was a massive hit, proving the song's universal appeal and enduring power.

From a deeply personal moment of connection at a concert to a global phenomenon, "Killing Me Softly with His Song" remains a testament to music's unique ability to articulate our innermost feelings, to move us, and to connect us through shared emotional experiences. It’s a song about vulnerability, resonance, and the overwhelming, yet beautiful, feeling of being understood through art.

Sources: